Divinity Atlas

Sacred Correspondences
Articles

Each Cure Caused the Next Disease

Citation Formats

General Reference

APA Style

BibTeX

Learn More
Each Cure Caused the Next Disease

Lascaux is the reason no major painted cave found since has been opened to the public, and the sequence by which it was ruined is worth setting out, because every step was a reasonable response to the previous one.

Four teenagers entered the shaft in September 1940. The cave opened to visitors in 1948. By the early 1960s about twelve hundred people a day were going in. Their breath raised carbon dioxide and humidity, electric lighting supplied energy, and green algae, the maladie verte, spread across the paintings, while calcite deposits began to veil them. Andre Malraux, as minister of culture, closed the cave on 17 April 1963.

Then the treatments began. Biocides and antibiotics were applied to control the algae, and the cave was stabilised with an air-conditioning system. In 2001 the system was replaced, and the works involved in installing it disturbed the equilibrium; Fusarium solani, a white fungus, spread rapidly across floors and walls and resisted repeated treatment. From around 2007 black stains appeared, caused by fungi of the Ochroconis group that were, in part, feeding on the residues of the chemicals used against the earlier outbreak. Each intervention created the conditions for the next problem. The cave is now monitored under tight restriction and entered by very few people for very short periods.

Facsimiles were built instead: Lascaux II in 1983, reproducing the two main chambers a couple of hundred metres away, and Lascaux IV in 2016, reproducing effectively the whole cave.

On what the paintings meant, the honest answer is that we do not know, and the confident readings have failed in sequence. Hunting magic, the idea that painting an animal secured it, collapsed on the evidence: the species painted are largely not the species these people ate, and reindeer, which dominate the food refuse, are almost absent from the walls. The reading that reached the public instead, associated with David Lewis-Williams, treats the caves as records of shamanic trance, with the geometric marks as entoptic phenomena seen in altered states. It has been sharply criticised (notably by Helvenston, Bahn, Bradshaw and Chippindale), on the grounds that it generalises from modern ethnography on other continents, that the neuropsychological model it borrows does not say what it is taken to say, and that it is close to unfalsifiable.

What survives all of it is modest and solid. Around nineteen hundred images, made over a long period, deep underground, at real cost and risk, to a shared and stable set of conventions. People kept coming back and doing it the same way. That is a great deal to know and it is less than a meaning.

Cross-Tradition Connections

Article On

Sources
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

View At A Past Year

The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.