A Committee Built to Keep Four Hymns in Five

By the early 1980s, the Seventh-day Adventist Church had been singing from the same hymnal for over forty years. Adventist hymnals seem to run on a roughly quarter century cycle, and the 1941 Church Hymnal had already outlasted that pattern. The General Conference Music Committee responded by assembling a nineteen member Church Hymnal Committee, chaired by C. L. Brooks with Wayne Hooper serving as secretary, and charged it with producing a successor.

The committee's finished choice was neither a wholesale replacement nor a light refresh. It kept roughly eighty percent of the hymns congregations had already come to favor from the 1941 book, judging that a hymnal succeeds only if people actually know and want to sing what is in it, while adding about one hundred forty new songs drawn from traditional hymnody, American folk hymns, contemporary gospel writing and compositions by Adventist songwriters themselves. The result, published in 1985 by the Review and Herald Publishing Association, ran to 695 hymns and 224 responsive Scripture readings across 830 pages. That balance, familiar enough to sing from the first Sabbath and new enough to justify replacing a forty year old book, is the quieter half of what a hymnal committee actually does: not choosing favorites, but managing how much change a worshiping congregation can absorb at once.