Svetambara Jainism holds that a woman can attain liberation in her present body, without needing rebirth as a man. The argument is that the qualities required are spiritual rather than anatomical, and that permitting robes removes the practical obstacle the Digambara raise. Svetambaras support the claim by identifying Mallinatha, the nineteenth Tirthankara, as a woman, and their canon records Mahavira as having ordained far more nuns than monks; today Svetambara nuns outnumber monks by a wide margin, an unusual balance among monastic traditions anywhere. Digambaras reject both the doctrine and the reading of Mallinatha. The disagreement is comparable to debates in Buddhism over whether a woman must be reborn male to become a Buddha, which some Mahayana texts assert and others deliberately overturn, and it turns in both cases on how far the body constrains the goal.
Facts
Status
Status Within the TraditionBinding, without a formal definition 1Tradition: Svetambara Held; Malli, the nineteenth tirthankara, is held to have been a woman Status Within the TraditionRejected, or not held, within this tradition 1Tradition: Digambara Not held Belief
SubjectSalvation and liberation 1 Category of Belief Learn More
Women Can Attain Liberation
The Svetambara tradition affirms that women can attain final liberation (moksha) in a female body, on the same terms as men. Svetambara Jains hold that ascetic discipline does not require the complete nudity the Digambara demand, and therefore that women, who take the same vows and wear the same white robes as monks, are equally capable of the highest spiritual attainment. In support they cite the tradition that Malli, the nineteenth Tirthankara, was a woman.
Svetambara tradition further points to Chandanbala, said to have been the first woman ordained as a mendicant by Mahavira himself and traditionally remembered as heading an order of thirty-six thousand nuns, as concrete precedent within the earliest community for women's full ascetic and spiritual attainment. The tradition's confidence in women's capacity is reflected demographically as well as doctrinally: Svetambara nuns (sadhvis) substantially outnumber monks today, in some estimates by a ratio of three or four to one, making Jain nuns among the largest organised female monastic populations of any living religious tradition, a striking practical outcome of the doctrinal position that liberation is as open to a woman as to a man.
Against the Digambara View
This affirmation stands in direct opposition to the Digambara position that a woman must first be reborn as a man to reach liberation, and the two views form one of the principal doctrinal divisions within Jainism. The Svetambara stance is bound up with their acceptance of clothed asceticism, since it removes the barrier the Digambara raise from the requirement of nudity. The entry presents the Svetambara affirmation as the branch holds it, within a long-standing internal Jain debate. The two branches disagree similarly about the biography of Mahavira, the tradition's own founder: Svetambara texts hold that he married Yashoda and had a daughter, Priyadarshana, before renouncing the world at around age thirty, while Digambara texts hold that he remained unmarried and celibate throughout his life.
As with the dispute over Malli's sex, each branch's account of the founder's life is consistent with, and arguably shaped by, its wider position on gender and renunciation, the Svetambara willingness to combine an ordinary household past with eventual liberation mirroring its openness to female liberation, and the Digambara insistence on a lifelong ascetic purity mirroring its stricter standard for who can attain moksha at all.
Cross-Tradition Connections
Sources
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.
View At A Past Year
The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.