Divinity Atlas

Sacred Correspondences
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme

Switch Atlas

The Inner World

The Civil World

The Natural World

Numerology Positions

Major Challenge

Challenge Number

Citation Formats

General Reference

APA Style

BibTeX

Origin 1908 to 1965

The absolute difference between the two Minor Challenges, read as the central and lifelong difficulty rather than a phase. It is the only Challenge derived from other Challenges, and because subtraction of differences collapses toward zero, the Major Challenge lands on the low digits more often than chance would suggest across a population. The scheme comes from the same 1930s layer of the literature as the Pinnacles, and like them it is one of the more traceable parts of the system. A person whose two Minor Challenges are equal carries a Major Challenge of zero, which the tradition reads as a lesson that must be chosen rather than one that is handed over.

Facts
Origins
Origin Period
1908 to 1965 1Tradition: Modern name numerology (Mrs. L. Dow Balliett and her successors)
Origin Period
The numerological chart and its positions were built in the United States between 1908 and the 1960s. Balliett's The Philosophy of Numbers of 1908 supplied the letter-value chart and the first positions; the pinnacles, challenges, cycles and personal-year figures were added by later authors. No position here is attested before the twentieth century. 1
Attributed Author / Compiler
Mrs. L. Dow Balliett and her successors. The atlas's own sources for these thirty-two positions name four different authors, Balliett in 1908, Cheiro in 1926, Florence Campbell in 1931 and Juno Jordan in 1965, for a scheme presented to readers as one system with one pedigree. The layering is the honest fact about them. 1Tradition: Modern name numerology (Mrs. L. Dow Balliett and her successors)
Attributions
Calculation
Absolute difference between the First and Second Minor Challenge 1
Identity
Number Category
Challenge Number 1
Learn More
The Challenge Numbers

Running alongside the Pinnacles, modern numerology sets a series of Challenges, numbers that name the obstacles and weaknesses a person must work through in each period, the difficulties that balance the opportunities of the Pinnacles. They are calculated by subtraction rather than addition, taking the absolute difference between reduced components of the birth date, so that where the rest of the system builds by adding, the Challenges are found by the gap between numbers.

The Major Challenge spans much of the life and is derived from the difference between the reduced birth month and birth day, with minor challenges governing shorter periods. Because a Challenge is often zero, when the two components are equal, numerology treats zero here as a challenge of a special kind, the absence of a fixed lesson. The Challenge scheme is part of the Pythagorean numerology built in the United States in the early twentieth century; like the Pinnacles it is a modern timing device, called Pythagorean by convention and not by any ancient descent.

Subtraction, and the Challenge of Zero

Everything else in this chart is built by addition. The challenges are built by subtraction, and they are the only positions that are. The Major Challenge is the absolute difference between the two minor challenges, which are themselves differences taken between reduced components of the birth date.

The choice of operation is doing the doctrinal work. Addition combines and produces something larger; the tradition uses it for what a person has. Subtraction measures a gap, and the tradition uses it for what is missing or unresolved. A challenge is described not as a quality but as a lack that has to be worked against, and the arithmetic is chosen to match.

Two consequences follow from taking a difference. The result can never exceed eight, so the challenge positions never yield a nine and never yield a master number; the highest possible gap between two single digits is eight, which caps the range in a way no other position is capped. And the result can be zero, which no additive position in the chart can produce.

Zero is given its own doctrine. It is read not as the absence of a challenge but as the hardest case, a challenge with no particular shape, sometimes described as the challenge of choice itself. That reading is not derivable from anything; it is a stipulation made to give the value a meaning, and it is the clearest instance in the chart of a doctrine written to cover an arithmetic outcome after the fact.

It occurs whenever the two minor challenges are equal.

Correspondences & Relations

Numbers

0, Numbers

A zero as the Major Challenge means the two Minor Challenges were equal. This is the most common Major Challenge in practice, since subtracting differences collapses toward zero. The tradition reads it not as a life without difficulty but as one with no assigned lesson, in which whatever discipline is kept has been chosen freely.

1, Numbers

A one as the Major Challenge names a lifelong friction over independence, present from the start and never confined to a phase. Being the difference between the two Minor Challenges, it is derived rather than direct, and the tradition reads it as the shape common to both of the earlier difficulties rather than as a third one.

2, Numbers

A two as the Major Challenge names a lifelong friction over sensitivity and self-effacement. Because it is a difference of differences, the literature treats it as the residue of the two Minor Challenges rather than an independent finding, and reads it as the form the person's difficulty keeps returning to.

3, Numbers

A three as the Major Challenge names a lifelong friction over expression, most often experienced as self-doubt that outlasts every achievement. The tradition treats the Major Challenge as constant rather than seasonal, which is what distinguishes it from the two Minor Challenges it is built from.

4, Numbers

A four as the Major Challenge names a lifelong friction over discipline, structure and limits, present in every phase of a life rather than in one. The literature reads it as the most wearing of the Major Challenges precisely because what it demands is never finished.

5, Numbers

A five as the Major Challenge names a lifelong friction between freedom and commitment, recurring in every arrangement a person enters. The tradition reads it as the Challenge least susceptible to resolution, since satisfying either side of it activates the other.

6, Numbers

A six as the Major Challenge names a lifelong friction over responsibility and the standards one holds others to. Because it is the difference of two differences, a six here means the earlier Challenges were widely separated, and the literature reads it as a difficulty that intensified rather than settled.

7, Numbers

A seven as the Major Challenge names a lifelong friction over trust, doubt and withdrawal, a persistent difficulty in accepting anything not personally verified. The tradition reads it as the Major Challenge most likely to be defended as a principle rather than recognised as a difficulty.

8, Numbers

An eight as the Major Challenge names a lifelong friction over material power and its meaning, and is the largest value the calculation can yield. Because it requires the two Minor Challenges to be maximally separated, it is also the rarest Major Challenge a chart can produce.

Cross-Tradition Connections

Disciplines That Use This

Numerology, Disciplines

The chart positions a numerological reading is built from, as distinct from the numbers themselves.

Source Esotericism and the Academy: Rejected Knowledge in Western CultureWouter J. Hanegraaff
Sources
1. Numerology: Or, What Pythagoras Wrought
Underwood Dudley, Mathematical Association of America (Spectrum series), 1997the chapter on Mrs. L. Dow BalliettView the Source
Your Days Are Numbered
Florence Campbell, The Gateway, 1931The Challenges
Quote, The Challenges
The Major Challenge as the absolute difference between the two Minor Challenges, read as lifelong.

Take a Related Quiz

Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

View At A Past Year

Choose a year to see this entry's facts and connections as the atlas records them at that moment: what it held then, what it held instead, and what it had not yet adopted. Choose Present for the current record.