Divinity Atlas

Sacred Correspondences
Religious Events

The Finding of the True Cross

Other

Citation Formats

General Reference

APA Style

BibTeX

The tradition that Helena, mother of Constantine, found the cross of the crucifixion at Jerusalem during her journey to the Holy Land in the 320s, at the site over which the Church of the Holy Sepulchre was then built. That Helena made the journey, and that Constantine built the church, are documented. The finding is not. Eusebius wrote about both the journey and the building and says nothing of a cross, and the story of the finding appears only later in the fourth century, in Ambrose and then in the church histories; one camp reads it as a legend attached to Helena afterwards, and another holds that relics of the cross were already being shown at Jerusalem within a generation of her visit, which is what Cyril of Jerusalem reports. Fragments were distributed widely from Jerusalem, and the feast of the Exaltation of the Holy Cross on 14 September is kept for the dedication of the churches at the site.

Facts
Disputed
When It Happened
Jan Willem Drijvers's Helena Augusta (E. J. Brill, 1992) dates Helena's documented journey to Jerusalem to the 320s CE, during the reign of her son Constantine, but notes Eusebius, the fullest contemporary witness to that journey and to the building of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, records nothing of a cross being found there; the fullest surviving accounts of the finding were written some decades later, beginning with Ambrose of Milan in 395, so the event's traditional date rests on the journey it is attached to rather than on any source written at the time. 1
Historicity
The earliest sources contemporary with Helena's visit do not mention the discovery; the story first appears in detail in writers active several decades later, leading most historians to treat the specific finding narrative as a later pious tradition. 1
Consequences
What It Settled
Led to the construction of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre on the traditional site, and to the veneration and gradual dispersal of relics identified as fragments of the cross across the Christian world. 1
The Event
Principal Parties
Helena, mother of Constantine, credited by later tradition with locating the cross on which Jesus was crucified during excavations near the traditional site of the crucifixion in Jerusalem. 1
Learn More
Helena's Search in Jerusalem

Christian tradition credits Helena, mother of the Roman emperor Constantine, with discovering the True Cross, the cross on which Jesus was crucified, during a visit to Jerusalem traditionally dated to the 320s CE. According to the fuller versions of the tradition that developed over the following decades, Helena undertook excavations near the site of Golgotha, then covered by a pagan temple that Constantine's building program in Jerusalem cleared away, and located three crosses along with an inscription, with the true cross subsequently identified either through its inscription or, in some versions, through a miraculous healing that occurred when a sick person touched it.

The discovery, in the fuller tradition, led directly to the construction of major Christian buildings on the site, including what became the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, and to the veneration of the cross as a physical relic, with portions subsequently divided and distributed to churches across the Christian world, a practice that continued for centuries and produced an extensive later tradition of cross relics venerated in numerous locations.

Helena's broader activity in Jerusalem, including the construction of churches at several sites associated with Jesus's life, is well attested in sources close to her own lifetime, giving the wider context of her pilgrimage a considerably firmer historical footing than the specific narrative of the cross's discovery, which developed in more detail somewhat later.

A Story That Arrives Decades Late

Historians examining the textual history of the True Cross discovery narrative note a significant gap between the traditional 320s date of Helena's visit to Jerusalem and the earliest surviving detailed accounts of the discovery itself, which appear only in writers active several decades later, in the closing years of the fourth century, a gap that has led most historians to treat the specific finding narrative, as opposed to Helena's broader documented activity in Jerusalem, as a later pious tradition that developed and elaborated over time rather than as an event recorded by contemporaries.

Eusebius of Caesarea, writing a detailed account of Constantine's building activity in Jerusalem closer to the actual events, describes the uncovering of the tomb associated with Jesus's burial in some detail but does not mention the discovery of the cross itself, a silence scholars generally regard as significant evidence that the specific cross narrative developed after, rather than alongside, the earlier and better attested account of the tomb's discovery.

Whatever the precise historical mechanics of its origin, the True Cross tradition became enormously influential in subsequent Christian devotional life, generating a vast later literature and an extensive practice of relic veneration that shaped medieval Christian piety, pilgrimage and church architecture for many centuries following the events the original narrative describes.

Cross-Tradition Connections

Associated With

The 14 September feast of the Cross rests on the tradition of the finding at Jerusalem, not on the crucifixion itself.

Helena, Historical Figures

Why this is disputed. Helena, mother of Constantine, is documented to have traveled to Jerusalem in the 320s, and Constantine is documented to have built the Church of the Holy Sepulchre there, but the specific finding of the cross during her visit is not recorded by Eusebius, the fullest contemporary witness to both the journey and the building. Jan Willem Drijvers's study of Helena traces the finding story to writers active several decades later, beginning with Ambrose of Milan in 395; one reading treats it as a legend attached to Helena after the fact, another holds that relics of the cross were already being shown at Jerusalem within a generation of her visit, as Cyril of Jerusalem reports, and historians have not settled which account is closer to what actually happened.

Belongs to Tradition

Related To

Sources
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

View At A Past Year

The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.