In 1914, an Anglican archdeacon, T. A. J. Ogunbiyi, founded a Christian compatible version of the society at Isale Eko in Lagos, initially calling it Christian Ogboni before renaming it the Reformed Ogboni Fraternity once both Christian and non Christian members, including women, had joined. The new fraternity kept Ogboni's structure of grades, its emphasis on brotherhood and mutual aid, and much of its ceremonial form, while removing the earth cult oaths and traditional religious content that had made membership incompatible with Christian practice for many educated, church affiliated Yoruba of the colonial period.
The Reformed Ogboni Fraternity grew far beyond its Lagos origins into an international fraternal organization with lodges outside Nigeria, adopting a stated motto drawn from scripture, behold how good and pleasant it is for brethren to dwell together in unity, signaling its self presentation as a Christian fraternal society rather than a continuation of traditional Yoruba religion. Its relationship to the traditional, earth cult centered Ogboni it grew out of remains a point of public confusion in Nigeria, since the two share a name and much ceremonial form while differing sharply in religious content.
Both branches continue today. Traditional Ogboni retains its earth cult ritual and its historic judicial role in Yoruba towns, while the Reformed Ogboni Fraternity operates as a chartered fraternal and charitable organization open to Christians, illustrating a pattern found elsewhere in this atlas, an initiatory institution generating a doctrinally adapted offshoot that preserves its social form while discarding the theology that a new membership found incompatible with an adopted faith.