Antoine Court de Gebelin announced in the eighth volume of Le Monde primitif, in 1781, that the trumps of the tarot preserved a book of Egyptian priestly wisdom carried west after the burning of the library at Alexandria. He offered no document for the claim and could not read hieroglyphs, which nobody could until Champollion. The assertion nonetheless became the founding story of the occult tarot and was still being repeated when the Thoth deck was named. Dummett approached the question the way a historian of games would, by asking where the physical packs came from and who was recorded playing with them. The answer that emerged is unambiguous and unromantic. The trumps enter the record in Milan, Ferrara and Bologna in the fifteenth century, in the accounts of courts that paid painters to make them, and the game they were made for is still played. The investigation matters to this atlas because it is the clean case of a documentary method settling an esoteric origin claim. It did not test whether the cards work, and it takes no position on what a reader finds in them. It established only where they came from, and on that narrow question there is now an answer.
Facts
Method
Method UsedPhysical packs, court account books, anti-gaming sermons and surviving rule books, read as a historian of games would read them rather than as a reader of symbols. 1 InvestigatorsMichael Dummett, later with Ronald Decker and Thierry Depaulis 1 Evidence
State of the QuestionNot overturned. Decker, Depaulis and Dummett extended the documentary work in 1996 and again in 2002, tracing the occult tarot to Court de Gebelin and the writers who followed him rather than to any earlier tradition. No historian of playing cards defends the Egyptian derivation. 2 Learn More
What the Documents Actually Show
The documentary record of the tarot is unusually good for a Renaissance game, and it points in one direction. The earliest secure evidence sits in northern Italy in the first half of the fifteenth century: a treatise by Marziano da Tortona, written before 1425 for Duke Filippo Maria Visconti of Milan, describes a deck of gods and birds ancestral to the trump idea, and account books of the Ferrarese court record payments for carte da trionfi, cards with triumphs, in the 1440s. The luxurious hand painted decks made for the Visconti and Sforza families survive in part, and their trump subjects, the Pope, the Wheel of Fortune, the Hanged Man, Death, the World, belong to the ordinary imagery of Italian civic processions and moral allegory, the trionfi of Petrarchan pageantry. For three centuries every mention of the pack, in sermons against gaming, in city statutes, in rule books, concerns a trick taking game, played from Italy through France and Switzerland into central Europe.
There is no document connecting the cards to Egypt, to the Kabbalah or to divination before the eighteenth century; cartomancy with tarot appears in Bologna and Marseilles records only in the 1700s, shortly before Antoine Court de Gebelin declared the pack an Egyptian book in 1781 without offering evidence. The gap between what the archive shows and what the esoteric tradition asserts is the entire subject of this study, and it remains the sharpest known case of a documented object acquiring an undocumented past.
From Gebelin to Dummett, How the Question Was Settled
Court de Gebelin's Egyptian assertion of 1781 was contagious because it was useful. Within two years the Parisian print seller and cartomancer Etteilla had rebuilt the pack around the claim, numbering and renaming the trumps for divination, and the nineteenth century esotericists, Eliphas Levi above all, wove the cards into the Hebrew alphabet and the Kabbalah, a synthesis the Golden Dawn systematised and Waite and Crowley carried into the twentieth century's standard decks.
None of these authors engaged the Italian archive; each inherited the previous author's assertions and extended them. The scholarly demolition came late. Playing card historians had assembled the fifteenth century evidence by the late nineteenth century, but the decisive work was the philosopher Michael Dummett's The Game of Tarot in 1980, which reconstructed the game's rules, lineages and diffusion from hundreds of documents and demonstrated that the occult tarot was an invention of French esotericism, an argument he and his co-authors Ronald Decker and Thierry Depaulis extended in A Wicked Pack of Cards in 1996, tracing exactly how, when and by whom the Egyptian and kabbalistic readings were fabricated. The finding is accepted by historians of the subject without serious dissent, which gives the study its atlas status: the documentary history is attested, the esoteric origin story is debunked, and the interesting question has become why the invented history proved so much more powerful than the real one.
Cross-Tradition Connections
Associated With
1980, Years The Documentary History of the Tarot Pack, a documentary investigation, is dated here from 1980. Whether the tarot pack descends from an ancient Egyptian priestly book, as asserted from 1781, or originates as a European card game.
Studied
The deck is named for the Egyptian god on the strength of a 1781 claim that the documentary history disposes of.
Sources
Essays About This Entity (1 essay)
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.
View At A Past Year
The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.