The founding narrative of Israel as a people: a child hidden in a basket among the reeds and raised in the household that ordered his death, a grown man who kills and flees, a voice from a bush that burns without being consumed, a series of plagues answered each time by a hardened refusal, a night of departure eaten in haste, a sea that divides and closes, a mountain that smokes while a law is given, and forty years of wandering that end with the leader shown the land from a height and buried outside it. The Qur'an names Musa more often than any other prophet and tells the confrontation with Pharaoh at length, with the magicians of the court believing on the spot and being threatened with death for it, and with a figure called the Samiri, rather than Aaron alone, blamed for the calf.
Facts
Disputed
Scholarly NoteThe exodus narrative describes Israel's deliverance from Egyptian slavery through Moses, a sea crossing and a covenant given at a mountain, with the Qur'an separately naming Musa more often than any other prophet and telling the confrontation with Pharaoh at length. Israel Finkelstein and Neil Asher Silberman's The Bible Unearthed (Free Press, 2001) argues from the archaeological record against a large-scale exodus as the Bible describes it, a position answered by scholars such as James Hoffmeier arguing for an authentic Egyptian background to the narrative; whether an exodus underlies the story at all, and on what scale, remains disputed between archaeologists and biblical historians. 3 Israel Finkelstein and Neil Asher Silberman's The Bible Unearthed (Free Press, 2001) examined the archaeological record for a large-scale exodus from Egypt as the Bible describes it, and found it does not support the narrative at that scale. Weighing that argument against James Hoffmeier's case for an authentic Egyptian background to the narrative, drawn from Egyptological evidence, the atlas records both published positions as readable and the underlying question, whether an exodus underlies the story at all and on what scale, as disputed between archaeologists and biblical historians rather than settled. Meaning
Central MotifDeliverance of an enslaved people through a called leader, a sea crossing and a covenant at a mountain 1 History
Historical NoteMoses is not named in any confirmed ancient Egyptian source outside the biblical and Quranic traditions themselves, so what is known of him as a figure rests entirely on those religious texts and their later interpretive traditions rather than on independent inscriptional evidence. 1 Historical NoteWhen Moses protests to God at the burning bush that he is slow of speech and tongue, God appoints his brother Aaron to serve as his spokesman before Pharaoh, relaying Moses's own words to the court throughout the plague narrative that follows. 1 Sources
Primary SourceThe narrative survives in the Masoretic Hebrew text of Exodus and, independently, across several Quranic surahs that retell the confrontation with Pharaoh and the plagues in a different narrative order and selection of episodes. 1 Text
Source TextExodus 1 to 20 and 32 to 34, with Deuteronomy 34 1 Source TextQur'an 7:103 to 7:157, 20:9 to 20:98 and 26:10 to 26:68 2 Scholarship and Forensics
Scholarly NoteAfter the Red Sea crossing, Exodus records Miriam, identified as a prophetess and Aaron's sister, leading the women of Israel in song and dance with tambourines, a celebratory scene set apart from Moses's own longer victory song that immediately precedes it in the text. 1 Controversy
Point in DisputeHistorians who accept some historical kernel to the exodus disagree on when it would have happened, with a thirteenth century BCE dating tied to Ramesses II favored by some and an earlier fifteenth century BCE dating drawn from 1 Kings 6:1 favored by others, a dispute separate from the larger question of whether it happened at all. 3 Learn More
From the Reeds to the Sea
The narrative opens with a new king who does not know Joseph, a policy of forced labour that fails to reduce the numbers of the Israelites, midwives who defy an order to kill the boys, and a mother who hides her son for three months and then places him in a pitched basket among the reeds of the river. He is drawn out by the daughter of Pharaoh, nursed by his own mother for a fee, and raised in the household that had ordered his death. As a grown man he kills an Egyptian beating a Hebrew, discovers the next day that the act is known, and flees to Midian, where he marries and keeps sheep. The call comes at a bush that burns without being consumed, where he raises objection after objection, is given a name for God that is a form of the verb to be, and is finally given his brother Aaron as a mouthpiece.
The confrontation with Pharaoh runs through ten plagues, each answered by a refusal that the text describes sometimes as Pharaoh hardening his own heart and sometimes as God hardening it, a doubling that has occupied theologians ever since. The final plague is met by a meal eaten in haste with blood on the doorposts, and the departure is by night. The pursuit ends at the sea, which divides for the Israelites and closes over the chariots. The song sung on the far shore is one of the oldest passages of Hebrew poetry preserved in the Bible.
Sinai, the Wilderness, and the Qur'anic Musa
Three months out, the people camp before a mountain that smokes and shakes, and the covenant is given there with commandments spoken to the whole assembly and a long body of law given to Moses alone. The episode that follows is the calf: while he is on the mountain the people ask Aaron for gods to go before them, gold is collected, an image is cast, and Moses comes down, breaks the tablets, and destroys it. The remaining forty years are a sequence of complaints, rebellions and provisions of food and water, and they end with the leader shown the land from the top of a mountain and dying outside it, buried in a valley in a grave that no one knows.
The Qur'an names Musa more often than any other prophet and returns to the confrontation with Pharaoh repeatedly. Its distinctive scenes include the contest with the court magicians, whose ropes and staffs appear to move until they are swallowed, at which the magicians prostrate and declare belief in the Lord of Musa and Harun and are threatened by Pharaoh with mutilation and crucifixion for it; the Qur'an makes their refusal to recant one of its clearest statements about faith under duress. Pharaoh drowns declaring belief at the last moment and is told it is too late, and the tradition holds that his body was preserved as a sign. The calf is attributed not to Harun, who is defended in the text, but to a figure called the Samiri, and the account of what the Israelites received at the mountain is told with the mountain itself raised above them.
Cross-Tradition Connections
Associated With
The parting of the sea and the drowning of the chariots close the story of Moses and the departure from Egypt.
Belongs to Tradition
Originated In
Related To
Sources
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.
View At A Past Year
The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.