Divinity Atlas

Sacred Correspondences
Rituals

Giyur

Initiatory Rituals

Citation Formats

General Reference

APA Style

BibTeX

Giyur is conversion to Judaism as shaped by rabbinic law: a course of study and testing of sincerity, acceptance of the commandments before a beit din, a rabbinic court of three, immersion in a mikveh, and, for men, circumcision or, if already circumcised, the drawing of a symbolic drop of blood. Judaism does not seek converts, and the tradition of turning an applicant away to test resolve goes back to the Talmud. The standards required, and mutual recognition of conversions between Orthodox, Conservative and Reform authorities, remain live points of dispute in the Jewish world.

Facts
Disputed
Standing as a Comparative Category
Used, but its validity as a comparative category is disputed 2Tradition: Judaism
Giyur, the halakhic process of conversion to Judaism, is codified in Moses Maimonides's twelfth century legal code the Mishneh Torah, which sets out the classical requirements of circumcision for men, immersion in a mikveh and acceptance of the commandments before a rabbinic court. Judaism has no single central religious authority comparable to a papacy that can bind every movement to one standard of what counts as valid recognition, so Orthodox, Conservative and Reform rabbinic courts each apply Maimonides's classical framework with different requirements and different degrees of strictness, and each may decline to recognise a conversion performed under another movement's standard. The method by which this is studied is comparative halakhic and denominational, reading each movement's own published responsa and conversion standards against Maimonides's codification and against each other rather than against any single ruling that could settle the question. Because the disagreement is structural, arising from Judaism's own decentralised authority rather than from any ambiguity in the classical texts, giyur's standing as a single, universally recognised process remains debated across the movements.
Scholarly Standing Detail
Moses Maimonides' own Mishneh Torah sets out the classical rabbinic requirements for giyur: study and testing of sincerity, acceptance of the commandments before a beit din of three, immersion in a mikveh and, for men, circumcision; modern Orthodox, Conservative and Reform authorities have each developed their own standards for interpreting those requirements, so what counts as a valid conversion is disputed between the three movements, with real legal consequences in matters such as marriage and burial where one movement may decline to recognise another's conversions. 2Tradition: Judaism
Practice
Who Performs It
The candidate undergoing the rite 1
Frequency
As the occasion requires 1
Solitary or Communal
Performed by an officiant for a recipient 1
Liturgical and Scriptural Role
Conducted before a court of three. The requirements are acceptance of the commandments, immersion in a mikveh, and for a man circumcision, or where he is already circumcised the drawing of a drop of blood. 1
Status
Current Status
In use across all denominations, but a convert accepted by one is not accepted by all, and recognition in Israel is a live political question as well as a religious one. 1
Observance
Observance Note
Rabbinic practice is to discourage the applicant at first, testing the seriousness of the request rather than seeking converts. 1
Attributions
Tradition
Judaism 1
Purpose
Admission to the Jewish people. Rabbinic law treats it as a change of status and not only of belief, and the convert is counted a Jew for every purpose from that point. 1
Meaning
Literal Meaning
Conversion, built on ger, the biblical word for the resident stranger, which rabbinic usage narrowed to the convert. 1
Function
Stage of Life Marked
Entry into the community or the order 1
Origins
Place of Origin
Ancient Israel 1
Historical Origin
Its core elements, acceptance of the commandments before a rabbinic court, immersion and, for men, circumcision, are laid down in the Talmud and later codified by Maimonides in the Mishneh Torah. 2
Learn More
A Path the Tradition Discourages and Requires

Rabbinic law asks a would be convert to Judaism to be turned away three times before instruction begins, a custom explained as testing sincerity in a tradition that does not proselytise and that has, across long stretches of history, made conversion actively dangerous under regimes hostile to Jewish practice. Once accepted as a serious candidate, the convert undertakes a substantial course of study covering Jewish law, practice, history and belief, its length and content varying by community and by the sponsoring rabbi or beit din, the rabbinic court of three that ultimately judges the conversion valid.

The classical requirements converge on a beit din's acceptance of the candidate's sincerity and knowledge, immersion in a mikveh, a ritual bath meeting exacting standards of construction and natural water source, and, for men, circumcision, or, for men already circumcised, a symbolic drawing of a drop of blood, hatafat dam brit, understood to complete the covenant physically as well as spiritually. Because Judaism has no single central authority, what counts as a valid conversion is itself a matter of real and consequential disagreement between Orthodox, Conservative and Reform authorities, and a conversion recognised by one movement is not automatically recognised by another, a division with direct legal consequences in Israel, where recognised Jewish status affects immigration and marriage rights.

Immersion, Covenant and Contested Recognition

The mikveh immersion that completes giyur is performed before witnesses from the beit din, who confirm that the immersion was total, unclothed and unbroken by anything separating the body from the water, and the convert typically recites blessings marking acceptance of the commandments at this point, the moment classical sources treat as the legal completion of the conversion itself, after which the convert is, in Jewish law, considered as though newly born, with family status and communal standing reset.

A chosen Hebrew name is usually taken at or before this point, often incorporating the honorific ben or bat Avraham, son or daughter of Abraham, reflecting the convert's new spiritual lineage rather than a biological one. The disagreement between movements over what constitutes valid giyur centres on questions the Orthodox world considers non negotiable, principally a full and sincere commitment to observe Jewish law as classically defined, and that Reform and Reconstructionist authorities, working from different premises about the binding force of that law, do not require in the same terms, producing conversions that stand as fully valid within one movement and are not accepted as such within another. Maimonides' codification in the Mishneh Torah remains a central classical reference point cited by authorities across the spectrum even where they differ sharply on its application to the modern convert.

Cross-Tradition Connections

Belongs to Tradition

Kept in Breslov Hasidism. Conversion requires acceptance of the commandments before a rabbinic court, circumcision where applicable, and immersion, and conversions performed outside this body are not recognised.

Kept in Chabad-Lubavitch. Conversion requires acceptance of the commandments before a rabbinic court, circumcision where applicable, and immersion, and conversions performed outside this body are not recognised.

Conversion requires circumcision, immersion and a rabbinic court, as in the halakhic bodies, and is nonetheless not recognised by them.

Kept in Haredi Judaism, where the halakhic standard is the strictest and the most stringent opinion is ordinarily followed. Conversion requires acceptance of the commandments before a rabbinic court, circumcision where applicable, and immersion, and conversions performed outside this body are not recognised.

Kept in Hasidic Judaism. Conversion requires acceptance of the commandments before a rabbinic court, circumcision where applicable, and immersion, and conversions performed outside this body are not recognised.

Judaism, Religions

Kept in Modern Orthodox Judaism, alongside full engagement with secular study and with the state. Conversion requires acceptance of the commandments before a rabbinic court, circumcision where applicable, and immersion, and conversions performed outside this body are not recognised.

Conversion requires acceptance of the commandments before a rabbinic court, circumcision where applicable, and immersion, and conversions performed outside this body are not recognised.

Source Shulchan AruchJoseph Karo

Conversion requires study and a public affirmation before a rabbinic court, and this movement does not require circumcision or immersion in every case.

Conducted By

Acceptance of the commandments is made before a beit din of three, over which a dayan presides.

Source The Oxford Dictionary of World ReligionsJohn Bowker (ed.)

Conversion is supervised by a rabbi, who prepares and examines the candidate.

Source The Oxford Dictionary of World ReligionsJohn Bowker (ed.)
Source Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd editionMichael Berenbaum and Fred Skolnik (eds.)
Sources
1. Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd edition
Michael Berenbaum and Fred Skolnik (eds.), Macmillan Reference USA, 2007View the Source
2. Mishneh Torah
Moses MaimonidesView the Source
Shulchan Aruch
Joseph Karo, 1565View the Source
The Oxford Dictionary of World Religions
John Bowker (ed.), Oxford University Press, 1997View the Source
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

View At A Past Year

The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.